The Best Car Insurance Companies for 2020

Car Insurance

The best car insurance companies are not just providing the coverage at a reasonable price but there are many other factors to consider.

To find out what kind of insurance you need, you have to know how much you want to spend and the type of cover you want. For example, you’ll want a third-party property coverage, if you want protection from damaging other people’s property, but do not want to spend much money on covering your car.

What to Look for in Car Insurance?

When you are shopping for a new car insurance make sure you look for the following things to help you evaluate the insurance company:

  • Personal injury and personal liability
  • Uninsured drivers
  • Getting stranded
  • Deductible vs. premium
  • Amount of driving experience
  • Solid ratings
  • Quality of customer service
  • Major accidents
  • Affordable premiums
  • Multi-policy discounts
  • Review your coverage
  • Do an annual rate check
  • Take advantage of discounts

It is always a difficult job to find affordable car insurance companies for your vehicle. But don’t worry we have listed the best auto insurance companies in U.S. for you. 

CompanyJ.D. Power AM Best FinancialConsumer Reports
State Farm3/5A++78
The Hartford3/5A+74
American Family4/5A76

Best Car Insurance Companies

State Farm

State Farm
Photo: State Farm

State Farm with almost 18,000 agents spread around the country is one of the top choices.

To be able to sell insurance, State Farm relies exclusively on its agents. Only State Farm agents can sell State Farm insurance, and their agents can sell only State Farm products.


  • Biggest company for car insurance
  • Wide selection of policies
  • Fantastic Mobile App
  • High-risk auto insurance


  • Higher prices than its competition
  • Expect hard upselling
  • Inconsistent service


geico Car Insurance Companies
Photo: Geico

Geico has various kinds of auto insurance policies and also offers different kinds of discounts. The company can help you save money on your policy and get cheap car insurance.

GEICO started by selling insurance to U.S. government employees and military personnel. Later, the company continues to grow and expand by including a customer base in the private sector.

GEICO offers the very best pricing reserved for safe drivers and consistently provides one of the most competitive rates.


  • Many standard discounts
  • Innovative mobile app
  • Financial stability
  • Easy repair process
  • Accident forgiveness without extra fees


  • Low online customer service reviews
  • Claims typically handled online


Progressive car insurance
Photo: Progressive

The Progressive Group of Insurance Companies has always lived up to its name by being one step ahead of the insurance industry and finding new and affordable insurance solutions.

Progressive claims new customers save $699 on average when they switch. Including unique discounts helps Progressive to offer lower rates.


  • Customizable coverage
  • Industry-specific options
  • Easy online access
  • 24/7 assistance
  • Innovative quoting tools & discounts


  • Average customer satisfaction
  • Higher premiums


Photo: Allstate

Allstate auto insurance is one of the best car insurance companies in the USA. The company has offered car insurance deals to thousands of people. The company’s market share continue to grow even though their customer service had complains from many drivers.

The Allstate Corporation is an American-based insurance company, headquartered in Northfield Township, Illinois

Allstate’s initial application process is fairly simple and takes just a few minutes to complete online.


  • Comprehensive quote tools
  • Plenty of discounts
  • Dedicated agents


  • Coverage costs tend to be above average
  • Rated average for customer service
  • Lacking several standard discounts


Photo: USAA

USAA is based in San Antonio, Texas, and it offers auto insurance exclusively to current and former US military personnel and their families. 

Military members and their families can get some of the lowest rates and best customer service in the industry. 


  • Easy online forms
  • Top-rated customer satisfaction
  • Driver discounts
  • Membership savings
  • Vehicle discounts
  • Complete line of financial services


  • Very few physical locations
  • Limited membership

Farmers Auto Insurance

Farmers Auto Insurance
Photo: Farmers Auto Insurance

Farmers Auto Insurance has grown into a Fortune 500 company that covers more than 10 million households with a wide range of coverage. 

Through a network of almost 50,000 independent agents, the company is able to offer its policies in all 50 states.

Farmers offers some of the best-priced home insurance policies and decent car insurance rates and it is one of the best car insurance companies in USA.


  • Decent claims processing
  • Solid discounts
  • Good customer service
  • Rewards Visa Card
  • Personal support


  • Expensive for younger drivers
  • Service depends on region

The Hartford

The Hartford
Photo: The Hartford

The Hartford’s auto insurance might be right for you, If you’re looking for great coverage with a suite of additional benefits like rate protection and post-accident care.

Even if you are not over 50 years old, you can still join AARP as an associate member.

The Hartford offers an excellent mobile app, which requires a fingerprint scan to log in. You can use the app to start a claim, download insurance documents, contact roadside assistance and more.


  • Exclusive benefits for AARP members
  • Nationwide availability
  • Superior consumer and financial ratings
  • Discounts for electric and hybrid cars
  • Free policy cancellation
  • Locally available agents
  • Digital claims reporting
  • Above-average customer service


  • Fewer discounts
  • Exclusively for drivers age 50+
  • No ridesharing coverage
  • No transport trailer coverage
  • Non-AARP members cannot apply
  • No travel expenses or trip interruption coverage

American Family

American Family
Photo: American Family

American Family Insurance has been rated by one of the top Car Insurance Companies in the states where provide insurance.

According to the Better Business Bureau, the American Family Insurance is rated with A+ rating.

The company offers many programs for teens and students, but it operates only in 19 states.

Just for signing up with American Family, you can get a 5% discount for the program called mySafetyValet. The program requires monitoring your driving behavior by placing a small device in your car.


  • Multiple discounts
  • Claim filing options
  • Innovative products
  • Excellent rates for older drivers
  • Good programs for younger drivers


  • Average website
  • Slow quote processing
  • Not many coverage options
  • Limited coverage area
  • Poor online customer reviews
  • Long claims process


The Hartford
Photo: Amica

Amica has been in business for more than a century and it is proud to be known as the oldest mutual insurer of cars in the United States..

Besides the standard comprehensive coverage and great customer service, Amica offers a number of perks and special programs to benefit customers.

Amica has a good reputation in the United States of America and has a very high percentage of customers who say they will buy insurance from the company again.


  • Exclusive benefits for AARP members
  • Pays dividends
  • Good for Young drivers 


  • Limited coverage area
  • Not always the cheapest

Buying car insurance should be given just as much importance as buying the car itself. In this post, we presented the top Car Insurance Companies in USA. If you have any suggestions, please let us know in the section below.

Check some of our other blog posts focused on Insurance to help you find your best options.

Natures Money

Read Previous

8 Best Financial Education Sites to Follow

Read Next

Top 10 Travel Hacks for 2020